Are these ugly?

80%20 ELIOTTE TOGGLE NAVY SUEDE
On sale at Little Burgundy.
They have a hidden heel, which has sparked much debate.
Most people don't like the hidden heel, I think I have to see it on a model (myself).

Lappy Toppy Sleevies

Dudes, which one should I get? I like the first one (saw it at Urban Outfitters), but I find much value in a handle.
The first two are a bit sk8rboi but I thought I'd throw it in for comparison.
Plus, if I get a grey one, I have some cool patches to jazz it up a few notches.

My coworker said that the wool material will make the laptop too hot in the summer.
I hope not, should I believe him? :(